A close up of a bowl of pink raspberry flavoured milk jelly

Made Milk Jelly

31st December 2022 - New Experience Number 45.

If you’ve never heard of it, this probably sounds a bit weird, and unappetising. However, it’s a blast from my past. I hadn’t eaten it in years, and I’d never actually made it. So this was a new experience with a nostalgic twist as I decided to try and make milk jelly.

Sweet Things

I very much remember my mum making milk jelly for us when I was little. It’s a bit like a blancmange. Researching into it, I uncovered it has the far more sophisticated name of ‘Flummery’.  I gave my mum a call to find out her recipe.

Evaporated milk and a packet of jelly on a plain work surface, ready to make milk jelly.
Only two ingredients needed for this make!

There are only two ingredients that I needed to buy – jelly cubes and a tin of evaporated milk. There were only a few instructions to follow too. This was the perfect quick win I needed. There was only half a day left of 2022. I still needed a few more things to reach the goal of trying fifty-two new things in the year. 

Jelly cubes in a pyrex bowl.
You can pick whichever flavour jelly you like.

Wibble Wobble - Making Milk Jelly

This was incredibly straight forward. These aren’t accurate instructions, but a rough guide to how I made it. 

  • Melt the jelly cubes into boiling water.
  • Once the jelly has dissolved and the liquid has cooled, add in the evaporated milk.
  • Mix everything up and then pour it into a mould or bowl.
  • Place it in the fridge to set.
  • Give it a couple of hours, and you’ll have a spectacularly sweet pudding.
An open tin of evaporated milk next to a jug of melted jelly ready to be mixed to make milk jelly
The jelly cubes had melted and cooled, ready for the evaporated milk to be added
Pink milk jelly mix in a pyrex jug
Mixed and ready for pouring

Proof In The Milk Jelly Pudding

The strong pink colour made it appear very unnatural. I spooned out the concoction into bowls. It didn’t look the best. However, it tasted sooo good! Sweet and fruity, a bit like a slightly wobbly mousse, but less bubbly and much smoother.

The Other Half was dubious as he neared his spoonful to his mouth, but he was soon digging in for more. A good result!

A ceramic bowl full of pink milk jelly
Pudding it to the taste test

Want To Try It Yourself?

  • If you like sweet things to round off a meal, you might enjoy making this simple dessert.

  • There’s not much hands on cooking involved, and can be good to make with children.

  • It’s a really easy recipe to follow.

  • I asked my Mum for her tried and tested recipe. Maybe you have a relative who used to make it you could ask for top tips?

  • You can follow the BBC Good Food recipe. They call it a ‘Flummery’, but it is what I know as a milk jelly. They also embellish theirs with a few add ons.

  • There’s also another recipe which is very similar to the one my Mum gave me. The instructions from Frugal Family are easy to follow too.

Cost Of Experience

  • It will depend where you do your shopping, but the ingredients to make this delightful dessert are very affordable.
  • Evaporated milk – 55p

  • Jelly cubes – £1

Recommendations

  • Make sure you give it enough time to set, otherwise you’ll be indulging in a gloopy mess.

  • Don’t worry if you don’t have a jelly mould. Whilst they are fun and mean you can create a more show stopping dessert, you can still enjoy the same flavour if you make it in a bowl.

  • Make sure your jelly mix has cooled before you add the milk, otherwise it might curdle!

  • You can make this look more exciting with many different decorations, such as fresh fruit, whipped cream, hundreds and thousands etc.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top